Member-only story

Unveiling the Truth: "The Big Conservation Lie" by John Mbaria

Edison Mitchell

·9.9k Followers· Follow

Published in The Big Conservation Lie John Mbaria

4 min read · 2 weeks before

192 View Claps

13 Respond

Save

Listen

In the realm of environmental conservation, a profound exposé has emerged, challenging long-held beliefs and sparking a heated debate. "The Big Conservation Lie" by John Mbaria delves into the complexities of modern conservation practices, unmasking their insidious consequences and offering a compelling alternative.

The Myth of Pristine Wilderness

Mbaria begins by dismantling the myth of pristine wilderness. He argues that the concept of untouched ecosystems is a romanticized illusion, imposed upon the natural world by Western conservationists. In reality, he asserts, human beings have always been an integral part of the planet's ecosystems, shaping and influencing them through their activities.

The Big Conservation Lie

by John Mbaria

4.2 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	1119 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Print length	:	210 pages
Lending	:	Enabled

Citing historical and ethnographic evidence, Mbaria demonstrates how indigenous communities in Africa and around the world have managed their environments sustainably for centuries, without the need for external conservation organizations. He argues that by ignoring these traditional practices and imposing Western models, modern conservation often displaces local people and undermines their livelihoods.

Conservation as Colonialism

Mbaria further contends that conservation has become a form of neo-colonialism, with Northern-based organizations exerting control over vast tracts of land in the Global South. These organizations, he argues, frequently operate with a paternalistic mindset, viewing local communities as obstacles to conservation rather than partners.

Mbaria provides numerous examples of conservation projects that have had devastating impacts on local communities. In Tanzania, the establishment of Serengeti National Park led to the forced relocation of the Maasai people, depriving them of their traditional grazing lands. In India, the creation of tiger reserves resulted in the eviction of forest-dwelling communities, fueling poverty and resentment.

The Commodification of Nature

Another troubling aspect of modern conservation, according to Mbaria, is the commodification of nature. He argues that conservation has become a lucrative industry, driven by the sale of safaris, ecotourism, and carbon credits. This has led to a focus on charismatic megafauna at the expense of less glamorous species and ecosystems.

Mbaria contends that the commodification of nature undermines the intrinsic value of the natural world. It reduces biodiversity to a source of economic exploitation, rather than a priceless heritage to be cherished and protected for its own sake.

A Humane and Equitable Alternative

Despite the grim realities he exposes, Mbaria offers a hopeful alternative to the current conservation paradigm. He calls for a conservation approach that is humane, equitable, and grounded in the principles of mutual respect and collaboration.

This alternative approach, which Mbaria terms "community-based conservation," empowers local communities to manage their own resources and benefit from conservation efforts. It recognizes the vital role that indigenous knowledge and traditional practices play in sustainable ecosystem management.

Mbaria provides numerous inspiring examples of community-based conservation projects that have achieved remarkable results. In the Maasai Mara ecosystem, the establishment of community conservancies has allowed the Maasai to maintain their traditional grazing practices while protecting wildlife and generating income through tourism.

"The Big Conservation Lie" is a groundbreaking work that challenges the prevailing narratives surrounding modern conservation. It exposes the flaws and injustices inherent in current practices and offers a compelling alternative that prioritizes the rights and well-being of local communities.

Mbaria's meticulously researched and passionately argued book is essential reading for anyone concerned about the future of our planet. It is a powerful indictment of the status quo and a beacon of hope for a more equitable and sustainable conservation model.